Heart rate zones appear on every fitness watch and in most training plans. They are a reasonable way of controlling intensity, but the numbers underneath them are rougher than the precision of the display suggests. Understanding where the estimates come from prevents a lot of pointless anxiety about being in the wrong zone.
How is maximum heart rate estimated?
The familiar formula subtracts your age from 220. It is a population average with a standard deviation of around ten to twelve beats per minute, meaning a substantial proportion of people sit fifteen or twenty beats either side of their predicted figure.
Other formulas, such as 211 minus 0.64 times age, are slightly more accurate but still estimates. A forty-year-old could genuinely have a maximum anywhere from roughly 165 to 195.
The only reliable way to know is a maximal test, which is uncomfortable and unnecessary for most people.
What are the zones?
Most systems use five zones expressed as percentages of maximum heart rate.
Zone one, around fifty to sixty per cent, is very easy recovery work. Zone two, around sixty to seventy per cent, is comfortable aerobic work where conversation is easy. Zone three, seventy to eighty per cent, is moderately hard, where talking becomes broken. Zone four, eighty to ninety per cent, is hard, where you can manage a few words. Zone five, above ninety per cent, is maximal and sustainable only for short intervals.
Boundaries vary between systems, which is another reason not to treat them as precise.
What is the talk test?
The simplest and surprisingly accurate method. If you can hold a full conversation comfortably, you are in the easy aerobic range. If you can speak in short sentences, you are working moderately hard. If you can manage only a few words, you are working hard.
It requires no equipment and adjusts automatically for fatigue, heat and illness, which a fixed heart rate number does not.
How accurate are watches?
Chest straps measure electrical activity and are accurate for most purposes. Optical wrist sensors measure blood flow through the skin and are reasonably accurate at steady intensities, but less so during intervals, cold weather, or activities involving gripping such as rowing or weights.
Wrist sensors commonly lag behind sudden changes in effort and sometimes lock onto cadence rather than heart rate.
What affects heart rate besides effort?
Heat, dehydration, caffeine, illness, poor sleep, stress and altitude all raise heart rate at a given pace. Cardiac drift means heart rate creeps upwards during long sessions even at constant effort.
This is why chasing a specific number on a hot day can mean running absurdly slowly, and why perceived effort remains useful alongside the data.
How should you actually use zones?
Use them to keep easy sessions genuinely easy. Most recreational exercisers run their easy sessions too hard and their hard sessions too easy, ending up in a moderate middle ground that neither builds an aerobic base nor improves peak fitness.
A practical structure is around eighty per cent of sessions comfortably conversational and twenty per cent genuinely hard.
What is heart rate reserve?
A more individualised method that accounts for resting heart rate. It uses the difference between resting and maximum heart rate, so a fit man with a low resting rate gets appropriate targets.
Most watches offer this as an option and it is generally preferable to straight percentages of maximum.
Should you test your maximum?
Rarely necessary. A supervised maximal test is uncomfortable and carries some risk for men with cardiovascular risk factors. For most people, using perceived effort and observing the highest heart rate seen in hard sessions is sufficient.
When does heart rate matter medically?
Seek medical advice for a racing or irregular heartbeat at rest, palpitations with dizziness or chest pain, or a heart rate that does not settle within several minutes of stopping exercise.
Some medicines, particularly beta blockers, lower heart rate and make zone-based training meaningless. Use perceived effort instead.
For related reading, see the rest of the training section.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.