A significant proportion of people do not respond fully to the first treatment they try. That is expected rather than exceptional, and it is a reason to change the approach rather than to conclude that nothing will work. The unhelpful outcome is disengaging from services altogether, which is common in men.
What counts as not working?
An adequate trial matters. For antidepressants, that usually means a therapeutic dose taken for at least four to six weeks, since earlier judgement is premature.
For therapy, it means attending a reasonable number of sessions and engaging with the between-session work.
If either was cut short, or the dose was low, the treatment has not really been tested.
What should be reviewed first?
Whether the diagnosis is right. Bipolar disorder is frequently first diagnosed as depression, and treatment differs substantially. ADHD, autism, PTSD and complex trauma are all commonly missed in adult men.
Whether something physical is contributing: thyroid disorder, anaemia, vitamin B12 deficiency, sleep apnoea, chronic pain and side effects of other medication.
Whether alcohol or drug use is maintaining the problem, which is extremely common and frequently understated.
Whether circumstances make recovery unlikely without change: debt, housing, an abusive relationship or a job causing the problem.
What are the medication options?
Increasing the dose within the licensed range is often the first step. Switching to a different antidepressant, sometimes from a different class, is the next.
Adding a second medicine, known as augmentation, is used in specialist practice.
Roughly half of people who do not respond to one antidepressant respond to a second, so switching is worth pursuing rather than concluding medication does not work for you.
Do not stop antidepressants abruptly, as discontinuation symptoms are common. Reduce with medical guidance.
What about combining treatments?
For moderate to severe depression, combining medication with therapy works better than either alone, and this combination is often not tried before people give up.
If you have had therapy without medication, or medication without therapy, that is an obvious next step.
What is stepped care?
Services are organised so that people move up to more intensive treatment if lower-intensity options do not help.
Guided self-help not working is a reason to request one-to-one therapy, not evidence that therapy is useless. Ask specifically to be stepped up.
When is specialist referral appropriate?
Where two or more adequate treatments have failed, where symptoms are severe, where there is significant risk, or where the diagnosis is uncertain.
Community mental health teams provide assessment by psychiatrists and specialist practitioners, with access to treatments not available in primary care.
Ask your GP directly about referral if you have been going round in circles.
What other treatments exist?
For treatment-resistant depression, specialist services offer options including certain augmentation strategies, and in some cases newer treatments and brain stimulation approaches, all assessed individually.
Access varies by area, and these follow specialist assessment rather than being requested directly.
What should you not do?
Stop engaging. Men who disengage after an unsuccessful first attempt often do not return for years, by which point things are considerably worse.
Conclude that you are untreatable, which is a symptom of depression rather than an assessment.
Stop medication abruptly or without discussion.
How long might it take?
Longer than anyone wants. Working through several treatment options can take many months, and that is a normal course rather than a sign of failure. Most people do eventually find something that helps, and persistence is the main predictor.
What should you do next?
Book a review appointment specifically to discuss that treatment has not worked, listing what you have tried, at what dose, for how long.
Ask what the next step is, and ask about referral if the answer is more of the same.
If you are struggling to keep going, call Samaritans free on 116 123, text SHOUT to 85258, or contact NHS 111 and select the mental health option. In an emergency, call 999.
More on this subject, and related ones, sits in the mental health section.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.