Back to Lifestyle

What If You Are Underweight or Cannot Gain?

Mens Health Guide Editorial 4 July 2026

Almost all weight content is aimed at losing it, which leaves a substantial minority of men unaddressed. Being underweight carries its own health risks, and unexplained weight loss can be the first sign of a condition that needs investigating. Both deserve more attention than they usually receive.

What counts as underweight?

A BMI below 18.5 is classed as underweight. As with all BMI use, it is a rough guide, and a lean, muscular man may sit low without any concern.

The more important distinction is between being naturally light and stable, and losing weight without trying.

When should weight loss be investigated?

See a GP if you have lost weight without trying, particularly more than five per cent of your body weight over six to twelve months. Unintentional weight loss needs assessment rather than reassurance.

Causes include overactive thyroid, diabetes, coeliac disease, inflammatory bowel disease, infection, depression, cancer, and medication effects.

Accompanying symptoms make assessment more urgent: night sweats, persistent cough, blood in stool, difficulty swallowing, persistent pain, or a lump.

What are the health risks of being underweight?

Reduced bone density and higher fracture risk. Lower muscle mass and strength. Impaired immune function and slower recovery from illness. Low testosterone and reduced fertility. Fatigue and poor concentration.

Mortality risk curves are U-shaped, with increased risk at both ends, though some of the risk at the low end reflects underlying illness.

Why do some men struggle to gain?

Usually because they eat less than they think. Naturally lean men often have higher spontaneous activity, feel full quickly, and eat only when hungry.

Some have genuinely higher energy expenditure through fidgeting and movement. Physically demanding jobs add substantially.

Others have underlying causes: undiagnosed coeliac disease, digestive conditions, thyroid problems, or chronic stress and poor appetite.

How do you gain weight healthily?

Aim for a modest surplus, around 250 to 500 calories a day above maintenance, producing roughly 0.25 to 0.5 per cent of body weight gain per week.

Eat more frequently rather than larger meals, since early fullness is usually the limiting factor. Four to five eating occasions a day works better than three large ones.

Use calorie-dense foods: nuts and nut butters, olive oil, full-fat dairy, cheese, oats, dried fruit, avocado and oily fish.

Drink calories, since liquids are less filling. Milk, smoothies made with oats, banana, peanut butter and yoghurt, and milk-based shakes all add several hundred calories easily.

Reduce very high-volume, high-fibre foods at meals, which fill you up before you have eaten enough.

Should you train?

Yes. Resistance training ensures that gained weight is largely muscle rather than fat, and it improves appetite for many men.

Two to four sessions a week, with progressive loading and adequate protein at around 1.6 to 2.2 grams per kilogram of body weight, is the approach with the best evidence.

Very high volumes of cardio work against gaining and may need reducing temporarily.

Does appetite improve?

Usually, within a few weeks of eating more regularly, as the stomach adapts to larger volumes. The first fortnight is generally the hardest, and eating to a schedule rather than waiting for hunger is what gets most men through it.

What should you avoid?

Gaining through junk food alone, which adds fat and affects cholesterol and blood pressure. Mass gainer supplements, which are expensive sugar and oil.

How long does gaining take?

Longer than most men expect. Gaining half a kilogram a week is a reasonable rate, and much beyond that is largely fat. A ten kilogram gain therefore takes five to six months of consistent eating and training.

When is it about body image?

Some men are preoccupied with not being large enough, a pattern sometimes called muscle dysmorphia, which is associated with distress and with steroid use.

If eating and training dominate your thinking or affect work and relationships, speak to a GP. Beat's helpline is 0808 801 0677.

You can browse more articles like this in our lifestyle section.

This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.