Back to Training

How Do You Choose a Personal Trainer or Coach?

Mens Health Guide Editorial 30 April 2026

A good coach compresses years of trial and error into a few months. A poor one wastes your money and occasionally injures you. The industry is lightly regulated, qualifications vary enormously in rigour, and the marketing gives almost no signal about competence.

What qualifications should they have?

In the UK, personal trainers typically hold a Level 3 qualification, with Level 2 covering gym instruction. These are the baseline rather than a mark of excellence.

CIMSPA is the professional body for the sector and maintains a register of practitioners meeting its standards. Membership is a reasonable signal.

Higher-level and specialist qualifications exist for strength and conditioning, older adults, and working with medical conditions. A degree in sports science indicates knowledge without necessarily indicating coaching skill.

Insurance and current first aid certification are basic requirements, and it is fair to ask.

What matters beyond qualifications?

Experience with people like you. A trainer whose clients are all twenty-five-year-old competitors may not be the right fit for a fifty-year-old returning after a back problem.

Ask who they usually work with and what results those clients get.

Communication matters as much as knowledge. A coach who cannot explain why you are doing something will not keep you engaged.

What should a good trainer do?

Start with a proper consultation: goals, history, injuries, medical conditions, medication, work, sleep and what you can realistically commit to.

Provide a programme with a rationale rather than a different random session each week. Track what you lift and measure progress.

Teach you to train independently rather than making you dependent on them.

Refer on when something is outside their scope, particularly injuries and nutrition requiring a dietitian.

What are the warning signs?

Sessions designed to exhaust rather than progress. Randomised workouts with no structure. No record of what you did last time.

Selling supplements, particularly their own brand, or aggressive promotion of products alongside coaching.

Offering advice on medication, hormones or anabolic steroids. This is outside any personal training qualification and is a clear signal to walk away.

Prescribing very low calorie diets or detailed meal plans without a relevant nutrition qualification.

Dismissing pain, pushing through injury, or claiming they can fix medical problems.

Some gyms include a limited number of sessions with membership, which is worth asking about before paying separately.

What does it cost?

Typically thirty to seventy pounds an hour outside London and more within it. Blocks of sessions are usually cheaper per session.

If cost is the barrier, alternatives include fortnightly rather than weekly sessions, small group training at a lower rate per person, or a handful of sessions purely to learn technique and set up a programme you then run yourself.

That last option is frequently the best value and is rarely suggested.

What about online coaching?

Increasingly common and effective for men who can already train safely. Typically a monthly fee for a programme, check-ins and form review from video.

It suits people with reliable technique and self-discipline. It suits beginners less, since nobody is there to correct what you cannot see.

Apply the same checks. Social media following is not a qualification.

What should you ask before booking?

What are your qualifications and are you on a register. Who do you usually work with. How will you structure my programme. How will we measure progress. What is your cancellation policy.

Most trainers offer a free consultation, which tells you more than any website.

What about nutrition advice?

Personal trainers can give general healthy eating guidance. Detailed meal plans, clinical diets and advice for medical conditions require a registered dietitian or nutritionist, and a trainer offering these is working outside their scope.

When should you change?

If you are not progressing after a couple of months, if sessions feel random, if you feel worse rather than better, or if you cannot ask questions comfortably.

For related reading, see the rest of the training section.

This page is general information rather than individual training advice.