This is one of the oldest arguments in fitness, and it persists because both sides have a point. Cardio burns more energy during a session. Resistance training preserves the muscle that determines what you look like once the fat has gone. Treating them as competing options is the mistake; they do different jobs.
What does cardio contribute?
Aerobic exercise burns more calories per minute than typical resistance training, because it is continuous rather than punctuated by rest periods.
It also improves cardiovascular fitness, blood pressure, cholesterol and insulin sensitivity, and is relatively easy to recover from, so it can be done frequently without interfering with other training.
Its limitation is that during a calorie deficit, cardio alone does little to protect muscle. Losing weight through diet and cardio without resistance training typically means a meaningful proportion of the loss is muscle.
What does resistance training contribute?
It preserves, and sometimes builds, muscle during a deficit. This matters for three reasons: muscle is what produces shape, it maintains strength and function, and it keeps metabolic rate higher than it would otherwise be.
Two men who lose ten kilograms, one who lifted and one who did not, can look very different at the end despite identical scale results.
Resistance training burns fewer calories during the session than steady cardio, though total energy cost is often underestimated because of the elevated metabolism afterwards.
What about the afterburn effect?
Excess post-exercise oxygen consumption, or EPOC, is the raised metabolic rate after training. It is real but modest, typically amounting to around six to fifteen per cent of the energy used during the session.
Claims that a short intense workout burns calories for days afterwards are marketing rather than physiology.
Is high-intensity interval training better?
HIIT is time-efficient and improves fitness effectively. For fat loss specifically, studies generally find similar results to steady-state cardio when total energy expenditure is matched.
The practical trade-off is recovery. HIIT is demanding and competes with resistance training for recovery capacity, so two sessions a week is usually plenty alongside lifting.
Does cardio interfere with muscle?
The interference effect is real but overstated at normal volumes. Moderate cardio two to four times a week does not meaningfully impair muscle gain or retention.
Problems arise with very high volumes of endurance training, particularly running, done immediately before or after lifting. Separating them by several hours, or doing them on different days, minimises any conflict. Cycling and rowing tend to interfere less with leg training than running.
How should you combine them?
For most men losing fat, three or four resistance sessions a week form the foundation, with two or three cardio sessions added, plus a high daily step count.
If time is limited, prioritise resistance training and walking. That combination preserves muscle and adds considerable daily expenditure without much fatigue.
What if you only have time for one?
Choose resistance training and add walking. That combination preserves muscle, adds meaningful daily energy expenditure and takes less recovery than adding hard cardio sessions on top of lifting.
Does fasted cardio burn more fat?
It increases the proportion of fat used during the session, but twenty-four hour fat loss is determined by energy balance. If you prefer it, it is fine. It offers no meaningful advantage.
What about the fat burning zone?
Lower intensity exercise uses a higher proportion of fat for fuel, but higher intensity burns more total calories. Over a day, total energy expenditure matters, not which fuel was used at the time.
How long should sessions be?
Forty-five minutes to an hour covers most resistance sessions, and twenty to forty minutes suits most cardio. Longer sessions are rarely more productive and are harder to fit in consistently, which matters more over a year than any single workout.
What is the practical answer?
Lift to keep muscle, do cardio you will actually sustain, walk more, and create the deficit primarily through food. The proportions matter far less than doing all four consistently.
You can browse more articles like this in our training section.
This page is general information rather than individual training advice.