Knee pain is one of the most common reasons men reduce or abandon training. The usual assumption is that something is worn out or torn and that squatting must stop. In most cases neither is true. The majority of knee pain in the gym responds to load modification and strengthening rather than to rest or surgery.
What is patellofemoral pain?
The most common cause, sometimes called runner's knee. Pain is felt around or behind the kneecap, typically worse going downstairs, squatting, running downhill or after prolonged sitting.
It usually relates to load exceeding capacity rather than structural damage. Treatment involves strengthening the quadriceps and hips, modifying aggravating loads temporarily and gradually rebuilding.
Exercise therapy is the best-supported treatment. Recovery typically takes six to twelve weeks.
What is patellar tendinopathy?
Also called jumper's knee, this causes pain at the bottom of the kneecap, worst at the start of activity and after it. It is common in men who jump, sprint or squat heavily.
Like other tendinopathies, it responds to progressive heavy slow loading rather than rest. Isometric holds, such as a wall sit or a held leg extension, often reduce pain enough to allow training.
Recovery takes months rather than weeks.
What about meniscus problems?
Degenerative meniscal tears become increasingly common with age and are often found on scans in people with no symptoms at all.
Several high-quality trials have found that exercise therapy produces outcomes comparable to arthroscopic surgery for degenerative tears, and surgery is no longer routinely recommended for them.
Traumatic tears with locking, where the knee physically cannot straighten, or a knee that gives way repeatedly, need assessment.
What about arthritis?
Knee osteoarthritis is common from middle age. Pain, stiffness after rest and reduced range are typical.
Exercise is first-line treatment and is recommended in guidelines. Strength training improves pain and function, and avoiding loading generally makes symptoms worse over time.
The old belief that squatting and running cause arthritis has not held up. Recreational running is associated with lower rates of knee arthritis than sedentary living.
Pain at the back of the knee is less common and can relate to hamstring tendon problems or, rarely, a Baker's cyst, both of which are worth having assessed if persistent.
Do knees going past toes cause damage?
No. This idea originated from a misreading of research decades ago. Allowing the knees to travel forward is normal in squatting and is required for full depth in most people.
Forcing the knees back increases load on the hips and lower back instead.
How do you modify training?
Reduce depth temporarily and rebuild range as symptoms settle. Slow the tempo. Switch variations: leg press, goblet squats, split squats, hack squats and box squats are often better tolerated than heavy back squats.
Reverse sled drags and step-ups are usually comfortable and build quadriceps strength.
Keep training. Prolonged avoidance weakens the muscles that protect the joint.
Cycling with the saddle set slightly higher than usual is often well tolerated and maintains fitness while the knee settles.
What strengthening helps most?
Quadriceps strength is the priority, since it is consistently reduced in men with knee pain. Hip abductor and glute strength also matters, particularly where the knee collapses inwards under load.
Progress gradually, using the pain monitoring approach of up to three or four out of ten during exercise, settling within a day.
Do knee sleeves help?
They provide warmth and compression, which many men find comfortable, and some report reduced pain during training. They do not stabilise the joint meaningfully, so treat them as comfort rather than protection.
When should you see someone?
Seek assessment for a knee that locks, gives way or cannot bear weight, rapid swelling within an hour of an injury, obvious deformity, or a hot, red, swollen knee with fever, which needs urgent attention.
See a physiotherapist for pain lasting more than a few weeks or not improving with modification. Many NHS areas accept self-referral.
The training section covers related topics in more detail.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.