Back to Training

Should You Rest or Train Around an Injury?

Mens Health Guide Editorial 8 February 2026

The instinct after an injury is to stop everything and wait for it to settle. For most training injuries, that is the wrong approach. Complete rest weakens tissue, reduces fitness and often leaves you returning to the same load that caused the problem. The better model is relative rest: reduce the load on the injured area while continuing to train everything else.

What does relative rest mean?

It means removing or reducing the specific movements that aggravate the injury while maintaining as much training as possible.

A man with a painful shoulder can usually still squat, deadlift, cycle and train his legs. A man with a knee problem can often still press, row and do upper body work. Stopping entirely because one joint hurts costs fitness, muscle and habit for no benefit.

How do you judge acceptable pain?

A widely used approach rates pain out of ten during and after activity.

Pain up to around three or four out of ten during exercise is generally acceptable, provided it settles within twenty-four hours and does not progressively worsen session to session.

Pain above that level, pain that increases during the session, pain that alters how you move, or pain that is worse the following morning means the load was too high.

Tracking this over a fortnight tells you far more than how it feels on any single day.

How do you modify training?

Work through the options in order. First reduce the load, often by thirty to fifty per cent. Then reduce range of motion, for example partial squats or floor presses. Then change the variation, such as swapping barbell bench for neutral-grip dumbbell pressing or back squats for leg press.

If none of those works, train the limb on the other side. Training one side produces measurable strength retention in the untrained side, known as the cross-education effect, which is useful when one arm or leg cannot be loaded.

When is complete rest appropriate?

After significant trauma, suspected fractures, dislocations, large muscle tears, or where a clinician has advised it.

Even then, rest usually applies to the injured area rather than to everything. Someone with a broken wrist can still train legs.

Why does complete rest cause problems?

Muscle strength declines within two to three weeks of inactivity. Tendons and ligaments lose tolerance to load. Cardiovascular fitness falls measurably within a fortnight.

This creates a common cycle: rest until pain-free, return at the previous load, and re-injure because tissue tolerance has fallen while the training demand has not.

What about tendon problems specifically?

Tendinopathy responds poorly to rest and well to progressive loading. Pain often settles with complete rest and returns immediately on resuming activity, because nothing has changed structurally.

Heavy, slow, controlled loading within tolerable pain limits is the best-supported treatment.

Cross-training also helps here. A man unable to run can usually cycle or swim, maintaining fitness while the injured tissue recovers.

Should you take painkillers to train through it?

Masking pain to continue at full load is a poor idea, since pain is providing information you need. Occasional simple pain relief for comfort outside training is different.

Regular anti-inflammatory use around training may also slightly blunt adaptation, so avoid routine use.

How do you return to full training?

Gradually, and usually more slowly than feels necessary. Return at around fifty to seventy per cent of previous load and build over several weeks, monitoring pain response.

Strengthen the injured area specifically rather than simply avoiding it. Tissue needs to be loaded to tolerate load.

How do you avoid losing motivation?

Set the goal as maintaining the habit rather than maintaining performance. Turning up three times a week to train what you can keeps the routine intact, and the routine is what carries you back once the injury settles.

When should you get it assessed?

See a GP or physiotherapist for pain lasting more than two weeks, pain that is getting worse, night pain, significant swelling, loss of movement, weakness, numbness or tingling, or any injury following a specific traumatic incident.

Many NHS areas allow self-referral to physiotherapy without seeing a GP first.

Other guides on the same theme are gathered in our training section.

This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.