Most men assume that if a supplement is sold in a shop, someone has checked that it works and is safe. In the UK, supplements are regulated as foods rather than medicines, which means the checks are considerably lighter than for anything prescribed.
How are supplements regulated?
Food supplements fall under food law, overseen by the Food Standards Agency and local authority trading standards. Manufacturers are responsible for ensuring products are safe and correctly labelled.
Crucially, there is no requirement to demonstrate efficacy before selling. No trial data is reviewed, and no licence is granted. Products are assessed after they reach the market, usually only if a problem is reported.
Medicines, by contrast, are licensed by the MHRA and must prove safety, efficacy and quality before approval.
What about health claims?
Health claims are restricted. Only claims on an approved register can be made, and each is tied to specific conditions and doses.
This is why labels use permitted phrases such as contributes to normal muscle function or supports the immune system, which sound meaningful and mean only that the product contains a nutrient with an approved claim.
Marketing that goes beyond this, particularly on social media and from overseas sellers, frequently breaches the rules.
How common is contamination?
More common than most people expect. Testing programmes over the years have found banned substances in a meaningful proportion of sports supplements, often steroids or stimulants not listed on the label.
Contamination sometimes occurs through shared manufacturing equipment and sometimes through deliberate adulteration to make products feel effective.
Independent analyses of products sold as research chemicals or advanced formulas have repeatedly found that a large share did not contain what was claimed.
Why does this matter?
For anyone drug tested at work or in sport, a contaminated product can end a career, and strict liability rules mean ignorance is not a defence.
For everyone else, it means taking substances you did not choose, at unknown doses, with unknown interactions.
What is Informed Sport?
Independent testing programmes such as Informed Sport and BSCG test batches of products for banned substances and certify those that pass.
Certification does not prove a product works. It means the contents have been checked against a banned list, which is a meaningful assurance if you are tested, and a reasonable quality signal otherwise.
How should you buy safely?
Buy from established UK retailers and manufacturers rather than marketplace sellers or overseas websites. Choose single-ingredient products at disclosed doses.
Be sceptical of anything promising dramatic results, anything described as a research chemical, and anything sold primarily through social media.
Check whether the seller has a UK address and contact details.
What about products bought abroad or online?
Rules vary by country. Products legal elsewhere may contain ingredients not permitted in UK food supplements, including stimulants withdrawn on safety grounds.
Importing supplements personally means you carry the risk entirely, with no realistic recourse if something goes wrong.
What about herbal medicines?
Traditional herbal remedies can be registered under a scheme that requires quality and safety standards but not proof of efficacy. Registered products carry a THR number, which is a better sign than an unregistered herbal product bought online.
Where do you report a problem?
Suspected adverse reactions to supplements can be reported to the MHRA through the Yellow Card scheme, which also covers herbal products.
Concerns about a product's labelling or safety can go to your local trading standards service.
Does the shop matter?
Established retailers have more to lose from selling contaminated products and generally have better supply chain controls. Online marketplaces where third-party sellers list products are the weakest link, since counterfeits and imports enter the system there.
What should you tell your GP?
Everything you take. Several supplements interact with medicines or affect blood test results, and clinicians can only account for what they know about.
Other guides on the same theme are gathered in our training section.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.