Back to Training

Is Protein Powder Worth Buying?

Mens Health Guide Editorial 2 March 2026

Protein powder occupies a strange position: marketed as a performance supplement, it is really just a convenient, concentrated food. It contains nothing your body cannot get from meat, fish, eggs, dairy or beans. Whether it is worth buying depends entirely on whether you are hitting your protein target without it.

What does it actually do?

It provides protein. That is the whole mechanism. If you are short of your daily target, it helps you reach it. If you are already there, it adds nothing except calories.

For men training to build muscle, the evidence supports around 1.6 to 2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight daily. For an eighty kilogram man, that is roughly 130 to 175 grams.

Reaching that from food alone is entirely possible and requires planning. Powder makes it easier.

Which type should you choose?

Whey concentrate is the standard option, typically seventy to eighty per cent protein, with some lactose and fat. It is the cheapest and suits most people.

Whey isolate is more processed, around ninety per cent protein, with minimal lactose. Worth paying more for only if you are lactose intolerant or cutting calories tightly.

Casein digests slowly and is sometimes used before bed, though evidence for meaningful advantage over whey is limited.

Plant proteins, usually pea and rice blends, work well. Single plant sources are lower in certain amino acids, so blends are preferable, and slightly higher intakes are sensible.

How does the cost compare?

Work out the cost per twenty grams of protein rather than per kilogram of powder, since protein content varies.

Powder is usually cheaper per gram of protein than chicken breast or fish, and comparable to eggs. It is more expensive than beans, lentils and milk.

The real advantage is convenience: thirty grams of protein in thirty seconds, with no cooking, is useful on busy days.

Blends combining whey and casein offer no clear advantage over either alone for most purposes.

Is it safe?

Yes for the large majority of people. Concerns about kidney damage from high protein intakes have not been supported in people with healthy kidneys.

Digestive discomfort is common with whey concentrate in men with lactose intolerance, and switching to isolate or a plant product usually resolves it.

Men with kidney disease should follow medical advice on protein intake.

What about heavy metals?

Testing programmes have found trace levels of lead, cadmium and arsenic in some protein powders, particularly plant-based ones, since plants take up metals from soil.

Levels are generally low, and the practical advice is to buy from established brands, avoid consuming very large quantities daily, and vary your protein sources rather than relying on powder for most of your intake.

When is it genuinely useful?

When appetite is limited, when training early and eating later, when travelling, when in a calorie deficit and needing protein without many calories, or simply when your schedule makes cooking three protein-rich meals unrealistic.

Does it matter what you mix it with?

Not really. Water, milk or a smoothie all work. Milk adds calories and protein, which helps if you are trying to gain weight and is unhelpful if you are not.

When is it a waste?

If you already eat 150 grams of protein a day from food. If you are using it as a meal replacement while ignoring vegetables and fibre. If you are buying expensive blends with added ingredients that do nothing.

Does it matter when you take it?

Far less than once believed. The anabolic window of thirty minutes after training has not held up well in research, and muscle remains sensitive to protein for many hours. Total daily intake matters considerably more than timing around sessions.

What about added extras?

Products with added creatine, glutamine, digestive enzymes or amino acid blends usually contain small doses at inflated prices. Buying plain protein and creatine separately is cheaper and lets you control the amounts.

The training section covers related topics in more detail.

This page is general information rather than individual nutrition advice.