Sugar attracts more alarm than almost any nutrient, some of it justified and much of it confused. The useful distinction is between sugars naturally present in whole foods and free sugars added to products or released during processing. The recommendations apply to the second group.
What are free sugars?
Free sugars include any sugar added to food or drink, plus sugars naturally present in honey, syrups and unsweetened fruit juice.
They do not include sugars within the structure of whole fruit and vegetables, or lactose in milk. Whole fruit comes packaged with fibre, water and nutrients, which changes how it is absorbed and how filling it is.
This is why blending fruit into juice converts it into free sugars while eating the fruit does not.
How much is recommended?
UK guidance recommends that free sugars make up no more than five per cent of daily energy intake, which is around thirty grams a day for adults, roughly seven teaspoons.
Average UK intake is around double that, with the largest contributions from sugary drinks, confectionery, biscuits, cakes, breakfast cereals and yoghurts.
A single 500ml bottle of regular soft drink can contain more than the daily limit.
Why does it matter?
The clearest effect is on teeth, where free sugars are the primary cause of dental decay.
Beyond that, high intake contributes to excess calorie consumption and weight gain, particularly through drinks, which provide calories without satiety. Sugary drink consumption is independently associated with type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
Very high fructose intakes from added sugars also contribute to fatty liver disease.
Is sugar addictive?
Not in the sense that nicotine or alcohol are. Highly palatable foods combining sugar, fat and salt drive overconsumption through reward pathways, but classic addiction criteria are not met by sugar alone.
That does not make cravings imaginary, and many men find intake easier to control once sugary drinks and snacks are less available.
How do you spot it on labels?
The nutrition panel shows carbohydrates of which sugars, which includes both natural and added sugars, so a plain yoghurt or milk shows sugar without containing free sugars.
More than 22.5 grams of total sugars per 100 grams is high; five grams or less is low.
The ingredients list helps: sugar under any of its many names, including glucose syrup, dextrose, molasses, fruit juice concentrate and honey, appearing near the start means a high proportion.
What are the highest-value changes?
Drinks first. Replacing sugary soft drinks with water, sparkling water, tea, coffee or diet versions removes a large amount with minimal effort.
Then check breakfast cereals, flavoured yoghurts, sauces and cereal bars, where content varies enormously between products.
Keeping confectionery out of the house makes more difference than willpower.
Are sweeteners safe?
Approved sweeteners have been extensively assessed by regulators and are considered safe at normal intakes. Claims linking them to cancer have not been supported.
The World Health Organization has advised against relying on non-sugar sweeteners for long-term weight control, on the grounds that evidence for lasting benefit is limited.
Switching from sugary drinks to diet versions is still a substantial improvement over continuing with sugar, even if water is better still.
What about children and family shopping?
The same principles apply and matter more, since habits form early. Drinks are again the highest-value change, and keeping sugary items out of the weekly shop is far easier than negotiating about them daily.
Does fruit count?
Whole fruit is not a concern for the vast majority of men, and higher fruit intake is associated with better health outcomes. Fruit juice and smoothies should be limited to around 150 millilitres a day.
What about honey and syrups?
Nutritionally, these behave much like sugar and count as free sugars. Small amounts of trace minerals do not offset that. Agave, coconut sugar and maple syrup are marketed as healthier and are not meaningfully different.
What about diabetes?
Sugar does not directly cause type 2 diabetes, though excess calorie intake and weight gain do. Men with diabetes should follow individual advice on carbohydrate intake.
More on this subject, and related ones, sits in the lifestyle section.
This page is general information rather than individual nutrition advice.