Statins and aspirin are the two medicines most commonly discussed for preventing heart attacks and strokes in men who have not had one. The evidence for each has moved in opposite directions over the past decade, and the current position surprises many people.
What do statins do?
They reduce the liver's production of cholesterol, lowering LDL, the particle that drives the build-up of plaque in arteries.
Trials consistently show that lowering LDL reduces cardiovascular events, with the benefit proportional to the reduction achieved. Broadly, each one millimole per litre reduction in LDL reduces the risk of major vascular events by around a fifth to a quarter over several years.
They also appear to stabilise existing plaque, making rupture less likely.
Who is offered them?
Men who have already had a heart attack, stroke or related disease, where the benefit is largest and treatment is standard.
Men whose ten-year cardiovascular risk is ten per cent or more, where treatment is offered alongside lifestyle change.
Men with specific conditions including familial hypercholesterolaemia, chronic kidney disease and some with diabetes.
What about side effects?
This is where perception and evidence diverge most.
Muscle aches are the most commonly reported problem. However, blinded trials have repeatedly found similar rates of muscle symptoms in people taking statins and placebo, and studies in which people alternated between statin and placebo without knowing which they were taking found symptoms occurred equally on both.
This does not mean the symptoms are imaginary; it means they are frequently not caused by the medicine. Serious muscle damage is rare.
Statins cause a small increase in the risk of developing type 2 diabetes, mainly in people already close to the threshold, which is generally outweighed by the cardiovascular benefit.
Liver enzyme changes occur and are usually minor. Concerns about memory problems have not been supported in trials.
What should you do if you get symptoms?
Report them rather than stopping silently, which is what most people do. Options include a break to see whether symptoms resolve, a lower dose, a different statin, or alternative cholesterol-lowering medicines.
Seek medical advice promptly for severe or widespread muscle pain with weakness, or dark urine, which can indicate rare serious muscle damage.
Why is aspirin no longer recommended?
For decades, low-dose aspirin was widely taken to prevent a first heart attack. Large trials published over the past several years changed that.
They found that in people without established cardiovascular disease, the modest reduction in events was offset by an increase in significant bleeding, including gastrointestinal and intracranial bleeding.
Current guidance therefore does not recommend aspirin for primary prevention in most people.
Does timing of the dose matter?
Older statins such as simvastatin work better taken at night because cholesterol production peaks then. Longer-acting ones including atorvastatin and rosuvastatin can be taken at any time, and consistency matters more than timing.
When is aspirin still used?
After a heart attack, stroke, or where there is established cardiovascular disease, where the benefit clearly outweighs bleeding risk.
If you have been prescribed aspirin after a cardiac event, do not stop it without medical advice. This article concerns people who have not had one.
If you are taking aspirin you bought yourself for prevention, discuss it at your next appointment.
Are there alternatives?
Ezetimibe is commonly added or used where statins are not tolerated, and newer injectable treatments are available for specific groups. Plant stanols, soluble fibre and weight loss all lower cholesterol modestly and work alongside rather than instead of medication where risk is high.
How should you decide about a statin?
Ask what your risk score is, how much the medicine would reduce it in absolute terms, and what lifestyle change might achieve.
Lifestyle measures and statins are not alternatives; they work together, and neither removes the case for the other.
Deciding against treatment after an informed discussion is legitimate, and the decision can be revisited.
For related reading, see the rest of the lifestyle section.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.