Sleeping tablets do work, in the sense that they reduce the time taken to fall asleep and increase total sleep time. The effects are more modest than most people expect, often amounting to falling asleep around fifteen to twenty minutes sooner and sleeping a little longer. The more important point is what happens with continued use, which is why UK guidance recommends them only for short periods.
What are z-drugs?
Zopiclone, zolpidem and zaleplon are the most commonly prescribed sleeping tablets in the UK. They act on the same brain receptors as benzodiazepines, enhancing the effects of GABA, the main calming chemical messenger.
They are usually prescribed for no more than two to four weeks, often intermittently rather than nightly. Guidance recommends the lowest effective dose.
What are the problems with longer use?
Tolerance develops, so the same dose becomes less effective over weeks. Dependence can follow, both physical and psychological, with anxiety about sleeping without them.
Stopping after regular use often causes rebound insomnia, where sleep is temporarily worse than before, which many people interpret as proof they need the tablets.
Next-day effects include drowsiness, impaired concentration and slower reactions. There is an increased risk of falls and fractures, particularly in older people, and a higher risk of road traffic accidents.
Driving while impaired by sleeping tablets is an offence, and some of these medicines are covered by drug driving laws. Do not drive if you feel drowsy the next morning.
Rarely, z-drugs cause complex sleep behaviours such as walking, eating or driving while not fully awake, with no memory of it afterwards. This requires stopping the medicine.
What about benzodiazepines?
Diazepam, temazepam and similar medicines are occasionally used but carry higher risks of dependence, daytime sedation and cognitive effects. They are generally avoided for insomnia except in specific short-term circumstances.
Does melatonin help?
Melatonin is a hormone that signals darkness to the body clock rather than a sedative. It is most useful for problems with the timing of sleep, such as jet lag, shift work and delayed sleep phase, and less useful for classic insomnia.
In the UK, melatonin is a prescription medicine. A prolonged-release version is licensed for short-term use in adults aged fifty-five and over. Products bought abroad or online are unregulated and vary considerably in dose and quality.
What about antihistamines?
Over-the-counter sleep aids usually contain sedating antihistamines such as diphenhydramine or promethazine. They can cause drowsiness but tolerance develops quickly, often within days, and next-day grogginess and dry mouth are common. They are not recommended for regular use, particularly in older men, where they can affect memory and worsen urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate.
Do herbal remedies work?
Valerian, chamomile and similar products have limited and inconsistent evidence. They are generally low risk but should not be assumed to be effective, and some interact with other medicines. Tell your GP or pharmacist what you are taking.
When are tablets reasonable?
Short-term use can be appropriate during an acute crisis, bereavement, hospital stay or a severe episode of insomnia where functioning is badly affected, ideally alongside a plan for what happens next.
What is recommended instead?
For insomnia lasting more than a few weeks, cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia is the recommended first-line treatment. It works as well as tablets in the short term and considerably better over months and years, because the benefits persist.
What should you ask your GP?
If a sleeping tablet is offered, ask how long it is intended for, what the plan is for stopping, and whether cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia is available locally. A short course with a clear endpoint is very different from an open repeat prescription.
How do you stop taking them?
Do not stop abruptly after long-term use. Ask your GP about a gradual reduction plan, ideally alongside CBT-I, which improves the chances of stopping successfully.
You can browse more articles like this in our mental health section.
This page is general information rather than medical advice.