Four tablets are commonly used to treat erectile dysfunction in the UK: sildenafil, tadalafil, vardenafil and avanafil. They all belong to the same group of medicines, called PDE5 inhibitors, and work in the same way. Overall, they are similarly effective. The main differences are how quickly they start working, how long they last, how food affects them and which side effects they tend to cause. For many men, those differences decide which suits them best.
How do they all work?
Each medicine blocks an enzyme called PDE5, allowing the blood vessels in the penis to stay relaxed for longer during sexual arousal. None of them causes an erection without sexual stimulation, and none increases desire.
What is sildenafil like?
Sildenafil, the original Viagra, is usually taken thirty to sixty minutes before sex and works for around four hours. A heavy or fatty meal can delay and reduce its effect. It is the most widely used, is available from pharmacies without a prescription, and generic versions are inexpensive and can be prescribed on the NHS.
Common side effects include headache, flushing, a blocked nose, indigestion and, less often, visual changes such as a blue tinge.
What is tadalafil like?
Tadalafil, originally sold as Cialis, lasts much longer, with effects lasting up to thirty-six hours. That is why it is sometimes called the weekend pill. It allows more spontaneity, as sex does not need to be planned around a narrow window. It usually starts working within thirty minutes to two hours, and food has little effect on it.
Tadalafil can also be taken as a lower daily dose, typically 2.5 or 5 milligrams, which keeps a steady level in the body and removes the need to plan at all. Daily tadalafil is also licensed to treat urinary symptoms of an enlarged prostate, which makes it useful for men with both problems.
Side effects are similar to sildenafil, but tadalafil is more likely to cause back pain and muscle aches, which usually appear twelve to twenty-four hours after a dose. Visual side effects are less common.
What about vardenafil and avanafil?
Vardenafil works in a similar time frame to sildenafil, lasting around four to five hours. Some men who do not respond well to sildenafil find it works better.
Avanafil, sold as Spedra, works more quickly, often within fifteen to thirty minutes, and lasts up to around six hours. It may cause fewer side effects for some men, but it is more expensive and less widely prescribed.
How do you choose?
Consider how you and your partner have sex. If you usually plan ahead and prefer a shorter-acting tablet, sildenafil is often a good first choice. If you want more spontaneity or have sex frequently, tadalafil may suit better. If you have urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate as well, daily tadalafil may treat both.
Side effects matter too. Men who get troublesome headaches or flushing on one medicine may tolerate another better. It is reasonable to try more than one.
Can you get them on the NHS?
Generic sildenafil can be prescribed on the NHS for any man with erectile dysfunction. Other PDE5 inhibitors may be prescribed on the NHS in certain circumstances, including for men with conditions such as diabetes, prostate cancer treatment or spinal injury, or if sildenafil has not worked. They are also available privately.
What safety rules apply to all of them?
Never take any PDE5 inhibitor if you use nitrates for angina, including GTN spray, or recreational nitrites known as poppers. The combination can cause a dangerous drop in blood pressure.
Do not take more than one type at a time or exceed the recommended dose. Check with a pharmacist or doctor if you take alpha blockers, certain HIV medicines or some antifungals. Seek urgent help for chest pain, sudden vision or hearing loss, or an erection lasting more than four hours.
What if none of them work?
Make sure each has been tried correctly several times at an adequate dose. If they still do not help, other treatments such as vacuum devices and injections are available, and your GP can refer you to a specialist.
More on this subject, and related ones, sits in the sexual health section.
This page is general information rather than medical advice.