Joint supplements are a large market, aimed particularly at men over forty with aching knees, shoulders and hips. The evidence for most of them is disappointing, and the intervention with the strongest evidence for joint pain is not sold in a tub.
Do glucosamine and chondroitin work?
These are the best known and most tested. Early small studies were positive, but larger and better-designed trials have generally found little benefit over placebo for knee osteoarthritis pain.
Some analyses suggest a small effect in men with more severe pain, though results vary depending on the form used, and the effect where present is modest.
They appear safe for most people. Glucosamine is derived from shellfish, so check labels if you have an allergy, and it may affect blood sugar control slightly and interact with warfarin.
If you try them, give it eight to twelve weeks and stop if nothing changes.
What about collagen?
Collagen peptides have attracted more interest recently, particularly for tendon and ligament health rather than arthritis.
Some studies suggest that collagen peptides taken with vitamin C around an hour before loading exercise may support tendon adaptation. The evidence base is small and early.
Collagen is a poor-quality protein in amino acid terms, so it should not count towards your daily protein target for muscle purposes.
Does turmeric help?
Curcumin, the active compound in turmeric, has modest evidence for reducing pain in knee osteoarthritis, with some trials finding effects comparable to anti-inflammatory medication.
Absorption is poor unless formulated with piperine or as a specific enhanced preparation, and cooking spice alone provides far less than trial doses.
It can interact with anticoagulants and may cause digestive upset. There have also been reports of liver injury with some concentrated supplements.
What about omega-3?
Reasonable evidence for reducing joint pain and stiffness in rheumatoid arthritis, which is an inflammatory condition. Evidence for osteoarthritis, which is primarily mechanical, is weaker.
What about MSM and boswellia?
Both appear in joint formulas. MSM has a small amount of supportive evidence for osteoarthritis pain, and boswellia has some positive small trials. Neither is well established, and both are usually included at doses below those used in studies.
What actually helps joint pain?
Exercise, consistently, and by a wide margin. Strength training is recommended in guidelines as first-line treatment for knee and hip osteoarthritis, and it improves pain and function more reliably than any supplement.
Losing excess weight reduces load on lower limb joints substantially, and reductions in body weight produce measurable improvements in knee pain.
Maintaining movement matters. Avoiding activity because of joint pain weakens the muscles that protect the joint and usually makes symptoms worse over time.
Does diet matter?
Indirectly, mainly through weight. There is no strong evidence that specific foods cause or cure osteoarthritis, though a broadly Mediterranean pattern is associated with lower inflammatory markers and supports weight management.
What about pain relief?
Topical anti-inflammatory gels are recommended before oral medication for knee and hand osteoarthritis, and carry fewer side effects.
Discuss oral anti-inflammatories with a GP or pharmacist, particularly if you have stomach, kidney or heart problems.
Is cracking or stiffness a problem?
Painless clicking and cracking is common and not a sign of damage. Morning stiffness lasting under thirty minutes is typical of osteoarthritis; prolonged stiffness with swelling in multiple joints warrants assessment for inflammatory arthritis.
Do any supplements build cartilage?
No product has been shown to regenerate cartilage in humans. Claims to that effect go well beyond the evidence, and the images used in marketing of worn joints being rebuilt are illustrations rather than results.
When should you see a GP?
See a GP for joint swelling, redness and heat, particularly with fever, which needs urgent assessment. Also for joint pain with weight loss or fatigue, pain in multiple joints, or pain that is not improving with exercise and modification.
The training section covers related topics in more detail.
This page is general information rather than individual medical advice.